Trials were carried out against Bennett's wallabies (Macropus rufogriseus rufogriseus) and tammar wallabies (M. eugenii) in areas of indigenous forest where browsing is preventing or damaging regeneration. Compound 1080 (sodium monofluoroacetate) in a carbopol gel was spread on the foliage of palatable plants. Numbers of Bennett's wallabies were reduced by 91% and tammar wallabies by 87%. These kill estimates compare favourably with those achieved using aerially sown baits. The costs per hectare of gel poisoning were estimated to be as little as 40% of those for aerial baiting, but the costs of using gel will increase as the control areas become larger, more rugged, and less easily traversed on foot.
The proportion of possums with cyanide-shyness was assessed in four populations and ranged from 12 to 54%. These results supported anecdotal evidence of cyanide-shyness and showed that the problem could be significant in some populations. Non-toxic baiting with rhodamine dye as a marker indicated that more than 90% of possums were willing to accept the bait material, and pen trials showed that possums were able to eat the bait material but reject the cyanide paste placed in the bait. Shyness was therefore not a result of bait aversion but of direct rejection of the toxin. Attempts to induce shyness in possums by feeding them sublethal doses of cyanide, and the history of cyanide use in the trial areas, support the theory that at least in some areas cyanide-shyness is not a result of previous exposure (learned aversion) but of primary aversion. Current research to produce cyanide formulations with low emission rates of hydrogen cyanide aims to make the toxin effective even in areas where cyanide-shyness has developed.
Introduction of the brushtail possum (Trichosurus vulpecula) to New Zealand has resulted in serious ecological and economic impacts and considerable control efforts. Recovery of possum populations after control occurs through immigration from adjacent areas and breeding of survivors and immigrants. If complete local elimination can be achieved, the recovery of populations will depend solely on immigration and therefore should be substantially slowed (particularly in very large areas). To compare the cost-effectiveness of four control strategies over the long term (60 years), we constructed a deterministic bioeconomic model based on 23 variables describing population characteristics, sizes of the sink (i.e. area controlled) and source (of reinfestation) areas, and costs. Sensitivity analysis showed that the most influential variables related primarily to cost and effectiveness of control, whereas factors describing immigration after control had relatively little influence. When the most influential variables were varied, the model predicted that local elimination of possums followed by 'perimeter' control is likely to be a more cost-effective control strategy under most scenarios than the current 'knockdown-then-maintenance-control' approach. Possum-control technology and its application have improved greatly in the last three decades such that it now appears that local elimination is, technically, a realistic goal, and is possibly already being achieved occasionally. Constraining factors include unreliable monitoring/detection at ultralow densities, inappropriate selection and use of control options, lack of incentive under the present contracting system, initial cost, contracting capacity, and the future regulatory status of poisons. However, these difficulties can be overcome, facilitating the adoption of long-term local elimination strategies that are better suited to managing possum populations in perpetuity.
Context. Brushtail possums (Trichosurus vulpecula) are a major pest of native biodiversity and agricultural production in New Zealand. To maximise the effectiveness of control operations, prefeeding (free-feeding) of non-toxic bait before poison is often used, but the mechanisms by which it does so, remain unclear. One possibility is that prefeeding changes foraging patterns and space use in ways that increase the likelihood of possums finding and eating a lethal dose of poison bait. Aim. To determine whether prefeeding along transects increases possum activity on the transect, and if so, how long the effect lasts. Methods. We monitored the time that radio-collared possums spent within a few metres of 350 m of aerial wire laid along a transect. Key results. Initially, possums spent only 2.6 min per night in the vicinity of the wire, but after 20 kg of bait per kilometre were placed along the wire, that time increased 20-fold on the first night and remained high for the next four nights (by which time all of the bait had been consumed). After that there was a gradual decline in time spent near the wire over a further 18 days. The increased amount of time spent near the wire was the product of both an increase in the number of visits and the duration of those visits. Conclusions. We conclude that sowing prefeed in concentrated strips is likely to greatly increase the probability of possums rapidly encountering toxic bait sown along the same strips, especially where the toxin can be sown immediately after all of the prefeed has been eaten. Implications. Possum control operations can now be designed to apply much smaller quantities of toxic bait that will potentially reduce concerns about 1080 poisoning because of a move away from broadcast sowing operations that are intuitively disliked by many, to much more localised baiting regimes.
A method is presented for quantitatively assessing the likely effectiveness of specific bait size and 1080 concentration for controlling brushtail possums with a known weight distribution. Data from aerial 1080 operations for the control of brushtail possums in New Zealand show that estimates of the bait size and toxic concentration required derived from the mean parameters [pest weight, bait size, and lethal dose (LD 95)] will not be accurate. This inaccuracy is most likely to lead to an underestimate of the amount of toxin presented to each animal, so that many operations currently run the risk of sub-lethally dosing possums and thereby possibly inducing some degree of poison shyness. On the basis of more accurate quantitative assessments of bait effectiveness we recommend that the 1080 concentration be increased to 0.15% and that baits less than 5 g be excluded to ensure that when mean possum weights are less than 3 kg more than 95% of possums are lethally dosed by a single bait.
Context Control of unwanted wildlife ('pest' animals) is undertaken for conservation and economic reasons, and when such animals are considered a nuisance. Such control should be undertaken using approaches that minimise, as far as possible, detrimental impacts on the welfare of the animals. Using a scientific framework based on the Five Domains model, the relative welfare impacts of pest control methods can be compared across methods and pest species.
Aims We demonstrate the application of a modified version of this framework to evaluate the relative impacts of seven Vertebrate Toxic Agents (VTAs) used to control brushtail possums (Trichosurus vulpecula) in New Zealand. The evaluation is used to produce a ranking of the seven VTAs based on their relative impacts on possum welfare.
Methods Scientific literature describing mode of toxic action, specific effects in possums or other animals and reports from human poisonings was collated as reference material for a panel of six experts. The panel produced a median welfare impact score ('none' to 'extreme') for each of the Five Domains. The 'Overall Grade' (1 to 8) reflected the intensity and duration of all impacts of a VTA on possums.
Key results All VTAs evaluated have at least moderate impacts on possum welfare, lasting for at least minutes. Cyanide was assessed as having the lowest welfare impacts (median grade 4), and cholecalciferol and the anticoagulants the highest impacts (7.5 to 8). Zinc phosphide was assigned an intermediate grade (6) with high confidence. While the overall impacts of sodium fluoroacetate (1080) and phosphorus were also assessed as intermediate (6), the panel's confidence in these scores was low.
Conclusions From an animal welfare perspective, anticoagulant poisons and cholecalciferol should be the least preferred options for controlling possums in New Zealand, as VTAs with less severe welfare impacts are available.
Implications The results of such assessments allow animal welfare impacts to be integrated with other factors in wildlife management decision-making and policy development, and are thus useful for managers, researchers, regulators and operators. Evaluation of welfare impacts aligns with the goals and mandates of ethical wildlife control and may also be valuable in wider wildlife research and management activities.
