Arendt, Scholem, Benjamin: Between Revolution and Messianism

In: European journal of political theory: EJPT, Volume 5, Issue 3, p. 261-279

Abstract

Walter Benjamin's idiosyncratic theory of revolutionary messianism was at the very crux of his influence on Hannah Arendt and Gershom Scholem. This article argues that Arendt adopted important aspects of Benjamin's idea of revolution, but rejected his messianism, while Scholem rejected Benjamin's belief in revolution and accepted his emphasis on the power of messianism as a political idea, but in a historical rather than metaphysical sense. As a result, in Arendt's and Scholem's political thought both the category of revolution and that of messianism as Benjamin understood them were radically transformed. This transformation attests to the wide-ranging impact of Benjamin's political philosophy, as well as to the complex and hitherto misrecognized intellectual relationship between Arendt and Scholem