Was Ptolemy of Lucca a Civic Humanist? Reflections on a Newly-Discovered Manuscript of Hans Baron
In: History of political thought, Band 26, Heft 2, S. 236-265
ISSN: 0143-781X
In his famous Crisis of the Early Italian Renaissance (1955) Hans Baron treated the Dominican political thinker Ptolemy of Lucca (1236-1327) as purely medieval, his ideas totally separate from the doctrine that Baron named civic humanism. However, in an unpublished, & previously-unstudied, manuscript written more than a decade earlier, Baron maintained that Ptolemy's ideology evolved into something quite close to civic humanism. He attempted to prove this through a comparison of early & late work of Ptolemy & through an analysis of Ptolemy's process of composition of his De Regimine Principum. This article analyses Baron's arguments & in general supports them, with some qualifications. Baron's manuscript supports the conclusions previously published by Blythe & is also significant in what it reveals about the intellectual evolution of one of the twentieth century's most significant historians of political thought. Adapted from the source document.