Strikes in China's export industries in comparative perspective
In: The China journal: Zhongguo yan jiu, Heft 65, S. 27-52
ISSN: 1324-9347
China's export industries witness outbreaks of spontaneous work stoppages and strikes that are often suppressed by the local authorities, sometimes with violence. To gain a perspective on these disturbances, and on what they reveal about China's industrial relations system, it is instructive to compare China with Vietnam. Even though the two countries have emerged from similar histories of Communist Party rule, their regulation of strikes is a study in contrasts. Chinese law does not mention strike actions; Vietnam, in contrast, has legislated complex provisions intended to regulate labor discontent by providing workers with a collective bargaining platform and with strike procedures when bargaining breaks down, to reduce the occurrence of wildcat strikes. We might therefore expect fewer strikes in Vietnam, but the reverse is the case: China experiences less frequent strikes than Vietnam. Also unexpected is that, even though the strikes in Vietnam are illegal, they are unimpeded by the authorities. In China, strikes, though not categorized as illegal, are nonetheless usually suppressed vigorously. This article will compare the course of strikes in China and Vietnam and examine the underlying factors, in order to understand this contrast. (China J/GIGA)