Suchergebnisse

Le présent article cherche à résoudre la question de l'inégalité économique des femmes à partir de la perspective de la théorie de la conception. Le concept des «problèmes pernicieux» qui a pour exemple paradigmatique, l'égalité des sexes, permet aux féministes d'examiner les multiples approches que nous avons adoptées dans le passé pour contrer les désavantages des femmes comme des éléments nécessaires et utiles dans la démarche menant à la résolution de l'inégalité. L'article passe en revue une diversité d'efforts au Manitoba, aussi bien que la mise au point de l'analyse fondée sur les genres par le Comité sur l'élimination de la discrimination à l'égard des femmes, comme exemples des façons par lesquelles les féministes ont abordé les problèmes pernicieux depuis des décennies et conclut que nous devons continuer d'exiger que les gouvernements mettent en oeuvre des politiques qui peuvent aider le Canada à se rapprocher de cet idéal d'égalité.

This article considers the defining moment embodied in the judgment of Chief Justice Brian Dickson in Brooks v. Canada Safeway Ltd when he proclaimed that it is "unfair to impose all of the costs of pregnancy upon half the population." The author argues that the case is important because of the history that preceded it and because of the breadth of its promise. She suggests that the promise has been somewhat betrayed by more recent cases dealing with the dual roles of many women as mothers and as workers that suggest a return to the formal approach to equality that Brooks clearly rejected.
Le présent article traite du moment décisif que représente le jugement du juge en chef Brian Dickson dans l'arrêt Brooks c. Canada Safeway Ltd où il affirme qu'il est « injuste d'imposer tous les couˆts de la grossesse à la moitié de la population ». L'auteure soutient que cet arrêt est important en raison de ses antécédents historiques aussi bien que par l'ampleur du changement promis. Elle suggère que cette promesse ne s'est pas réalisée dans les décisions récentes portant sur le double rôle de nombreuses femmes qui cumulent la maternité et le travail, ce qui laisse présager un retour à l'approche formelle de l'égalité que l'arrêt Brooks avait clairement rejeté. In 1989, Chief Justice Brian Dickson of the Supreme Court of Canada recognized in Brooks v. Canada Safeway Ltd.1 that a woman who was discriminated against because of pregnancy was discriminated against on the basis of sex and that such discrimination was contrary to both human rights legislation and the equality guarantee of the Canadian Charter of

Dans le présent article, les auteures—une experte en études critiques de l'incapacité et une professeure de droit—analysent d'un œil critique une décision de la Cour d'appel fédérale qui soulève des questions de genre et d'incapacité. La cause porte sur l'accès aux prestations d'invalidité du Régime de pensions du Canada. Cynthia Harris, une mère qui a la sclérose en plaques, conteste l'application de la clause d'exclusion pour élever des enfants contenue dans le Régime de pensions du Canada. Mme Harris conteste la disposition pour la raison que le handicap de son enfant l'oblige à lui donner des soins parentaux plus longtemps que s'il s'agissait d'un enfant non handicapé. Les auteures critiquent les différentes approches visant à comprendre le concept d'égalité et son application aux questions d'incapacité et de genre. Elles prêtent une attention particulière aux critères de participation à la vie active dans la législation sur la prestation d'aide sociale et aux effets qu'elle produit sur les femmes, surtout celles ayant des handicaps. Elles réfléchissent sur l'approche formaliste de l'égalité et de sa compréhension ainsi que sur l'absence d'une analyse intersectionnelle dans le jugement. Il faut des réponses systémiques plutôt qu'individualisées pour bien accommoder les personnes en quête d'égalité. Les auteures soutiennent que pour envisager de telles revendications à l'égalité, il faudrait une approche théorique qui privilégie l'inclusion et la citoyenneté sociale.

ObjectiveThe objective was to examine the relationship between maternal intimate partner violence (IPV) victimization and children's developmental health using linked population-wide administrative datasets. We examined developmental vulnerability (DV) at kindergarten of children exposed to maternal IPV victimization aged 0 to 5 using provincial prosecution records compared to unexposed counterparts.
ApproachThis retrospective cohort study linked administrative datasets (legal, health, education, social services) from the Population Research Data Repository at the Manitoba Centre for Health Policy. Exposed mother-child pairs with 1+ prosecution records of maternal IPV victimization during early childhood (child aged 0 to 5) between 2003-2018 in Manitoba (n = 5,728) were matched to unexposed pairs (1:3) based on sex/birthdate of child and neighbourhood income. DV at kindergarten was measured across 5 domains (physical, social, emotional, language/cognitive [LC], communication/general knowledge) using the Early Developmental Instrument (EDI). Children without eligible EDI scores were excluded. Multiple logistic regression models were conducted.
ResultsThe cohort included 5321 children (exposed n=1365, unexposed n=3956). 32.98% of the cohort was developmentally vulnerable in one or more domains (1/+) and 19.60% was developmentally vulnerable in two or more domains (2/+). Unadjusted relationships between maternal IPV victimization from age 0 to 5 and developmental vulnerability at kindergarten were statistically significant across all 5 domains (e.g., LC OR=2.76 [2.36, 3.23]) and in 1/+ (OR=2.72 [2.39, 3.09]) as well as 2/+ (OR=2.89 [2.51, 3.34]) domains. After adjusting for covariates, children who were exposed to maternal IPV victimization from ages 0 to 5 had increased odds of being developmentally vulnerable in social competence (aOR=1.33 [1.07, 1.66]) and emotional maturity (aOR=1.29 [1.03, 1.62]), also in 2/+ domains (aOR=1.42 [1.15, 1.73]) at kindergarten, compared to unexposed counterparts.
ConclusionThe study provided Canadian population-wide evidence of the association between maternal IPV victimization and early childhood development, specifically later socio-emotional vulnerability. Interventions and support systems for this population of families should be developed and implemented, with an emphasis on mitigating long-term socio-emotional developmental risks in children exposed to IPV.

ObjectiveUsing population-wide administrative data, the objective was to provide Canadian evidence on the longitudinal relationship between maternal intimate partner violence (IPV) victimization and children's developmental health. Using provincial prosecution records, we examined developmental vulnerability (DV) at kindergarten of children prenatally exposed to maternal IPV victimization compared to unexposed counterparts.
ApproachThis retrospective cohort study linked administrative datasets (legal, health, education, social services) from the Population Research Data Repository at the Manitoba Centre for Health Policy. Exposed mother-child pairs with 1+ prosecution record of maternal IPV victimization during pregnancy between 2003 and 2018 in Manitoba (n = 1,117) were matched to unexposed pairs (1:3) based on sex/birthdate of child and neighbourhood income. DV at kindergarten was measured across 5 domains (physical, social, emotional, language/cognitive [LC], communication/general knowledge) using the Early Developmental Instrument (EDI). Children without eligible EDI scores were excluded. Multiple logistic regression models were conducted to address the objective.
ResultsThe eligible cohort included 927 children (exposed n=229, unexposed n=698); 31.07% of the cohort was developmentally vulnerable in one or more domains (1/+) and 19.53% was developmentally vulnerable in two or more domains (2/+). Children who were prenatally exposed to maternal IPV victimization had increased odds of vulnerability across all 5 developmental domains (e.g., physical health/wellness: OR=2.83[1.95,4.10]; LC development: OR=2.45[1.65,3.64]). Unadjusted ORs showed statistically significant associations between maternal exposure of prenatal IPV victimization and DV in 1/+ (OR=2.70[1.98,3.68]) and 2/+ (OR=2.48[1.75,3.50]). When adjusted for covariates (e.g., maternal income assistance, mental health, child abuse history), no statistically significant relationship was found for any of the domains (e.g., LC development: aOR=0.98[0.53,1.81]), 1/+ (aOR=1.17[0.72,1.88]), and 2/+ (aOR=1.14[0.67,1.95]).
ConclusionThe unadjusted, statistically significant associations suggest children exposed to maternal IPV victimization prenatally may face associated social/health risks. The finding highlights the need to consider potential factors that put children at risk of DV when developing and implementing support systems/interventions for children exposed to maternal IPV victimization.

IntroductionRoutine health care information systems only capture a portion of violence against women because some victimized women may not seek health care and some events may not require medical attention. Population-based estimates of the risk of violent injury (VI) among women with a history of intimate partner victimization (IPV) are lacking.
Objectives and ApproachTo determine the risk of violent injury following IPV among women living in Manitoba, Canada, 2004-2016. Linked administrative justice, healthcare, and social databases were used. Exposure began after a woman was first involved with the Manitoba Justice system as a victim of IPV, assessed through provincial prosecution and disposition records. IPV victims (n= 20,469) were matched to three non-victims (n= 61,407) on age, relationship status and place of residence at the date of the IPV incident. The main outcomes were first health care use for violent injury and violent death. Outcomes were assessed through emergency department, hospital and vital statistics records. Conditional Cox Regression was used to obtain Hazard Ratios with 95% confidence intervals (CI).
ResultsThe crude risk of VI was 8.5 per 1000 women among non-victims and 55.8 among victims of IPV. Compared to non-victims, IPV victims were 3.8 [95% confidence interval (CI): 3.4, 4.3] times more likely to suffer IIIO and 4.5 [95% CI: 2.3, 9.0] times to have a violent death, after adjustment. Victims had approximately half the risk of VI if the accused is on probation.
Conclusion / ImplicationsJustice System-identified victims of IPV are at higher risk of assault and violent death than women not exposed to IPV. Justice involvement represents an opportunity for prevention of violent injury and homicide among IPV victims.

IntroductionManitoba has one of the highest rates of children taken into care of child welfare services (Child and Family Services; CFS) in the world, and also one of the highest youth incarceration rates in Canada. Policy-makers recognize there is overlap between these systems; the extent of that overlap is unknown.
Objectives and ApproachWe linked CFS, Justice, and Population Health Registry data to quantify the overlap between having a history of CFS during childhood (0-17 years) and being charged with a crime as a youth (12-17 years). Using a cohort approach, we selected all individuals in Manitoba who were born in 1988 (N=28,178); those not in the province at any time from 12-17 years were excluded, leaving a final cohort of 18,182. The cohort was divided into 3 groups according to CFS involvement: CFS out-of-home care (1,148); CFS in-home services (3,395); no CFS (13,639). Criminal charges between 12-17 years were identified.
Results6.3% of our cohort had CFS out-of-home care, 18.7% received CFS in-home services, and 75% had no CFS involvement. 10.5% of the cohort were charged of a crime between 12-17 years. Almost half (46.6%) of youth who had CFS out-of-home care had criminal charges, compared to 19.4% of youth who had CFS in-home services, and 5.3% of youth with no CFS. Despite accounting for only 6.3% of the cohort, youth who had out-of-home care accounted for 28.0% of youth with criminal charges. Indigenous (First Nations (FN) and Metis) children/youth were over-represented in both systems; for example, 24.5% of FN youth had been in care compared to 3.1% of non-Indigenous; and 32.2% of FN youth were charged with a crime compared to 6.6% of non-Indigenous youth.
Conclusion/ImplicationsThere is substantial overlap between the child welfare and youth justice systems, with overrepresentation of Indigenous youth in both systems. Culturally appropriate programs and policies aimed at supporting parents, families and communities to care for their own children will likely have long-term positive impacts on the youth justice system.

ObjectiveManitoba has one of the highest incarceration rates among Canadian provinces, and because of Canada's racist and colonial policies, the number of Métis women in custody is disproportionately high. In this study, we examined birth outcomes among Métis and all other Manitoba women who were incarcerated while pregnant.
ApproachUsing linked administrative health and justice system data, we developed a 2004-2017 cohort of mother-infant dyads with a live birth (n= mothers; n= infants). We identified all Métis mother-infant dyads, and then divided them into 3 mutually exclusive groups: a) prenatal incarceration; b) post-natal incarceration; c) no incarceration. We developed matched comparison groups for each exposure based on Métis identity, maternal age, geography and income, and, after adjusting for other potentially confounding variables (e.g., maternal age, maternal mental health, and socioeconomic factors), we examined risk differences in birth outcomes among Métis women and infants between exposure groups.
ResultsThe cohort included n=534 mothers who were incarcerated while pregnant (a), n=1,677 mothers incarcerated postnatally (b), and n=14,084 mothers never incarcerated (c). When we compared prenatal vs postnatal incarceration (a vs b), we found that women incarcerated during the prenatal period were more likely to have a low birth weight infant (RD: 4.2, 95% CI: 3.0, 5.4), preterm birth (RD: 5.1, 95% CI: 3.7, 6.5) or Caesarean birth (RD: 5.5, 95% CI: 3.8, 7.1) and were less likely to have a large-for-gestational-age infant (RD: -3.8, 95% CI: -5.1, -2.5) or to initiate breast feeding (-3.4, 95% CI: -5.5, -1.3). In the prenatal vs no incarceration comparison (a vs c), the same outcomes were statistically significant as above; however, the risk differences were even more pronounced.
ConclusionPrenatal incarceration is associated with poor birth outcomes for all mothers and infants in Manitoba; however, Métis women and children are disproportionately affected, further perpetuating inequities they may already experience. Canadians must acknowledge the harms of racist policies and practices, and work to support the health and well-being of Métis people.

IntroductionThe leveraging of multi-sector, whole-population, linked administrative data is advantageous for conducting research on complex real-world problems. However, such large and complex data repositories can sometimes appear impersonal and overwhelming. Establishing organizational empathy (OE) in thecontext of a multi-sector partnership between academic, government and community representatives can help us understand the data better for social policy research. Evidence stemming from this research can then inform policy decisions, ultimately increasing the potency of linked data analysis and creating more meaningful student experiences. Our objective is to examine the role of OE in the student research experience.
Objectives and ApproachSPECTRUM (Social Policy Evaluation Collaborative Team Research at Universities in Manitoba) is a multi-disciplinary partnership working to provide evidence-based solutions to 'wicked' social issues by using linked data from multiple sectors. SPECTRUM provides fellowships to students to become partners in the collaboration. Students have participated in quarterly workshops, building relationships with community leaders, government decision-makers and academic researchers. Students are from various faculties, bringing their unique frameworks and research interests to the collective. Through OE, students observeand participate in SPECTRUM, relating its goals and outcomes to society and their own research.
ResultsStudent inclusion in SPECTRUM enhances the partnership by providing a greater range of perspectives and facilitates the development of OE among SPECTRUM members. Students are using linked administrative data, while actively engaging in dialogue with stakeholders, thereby enriching their knowledge and understanding of research.
Conclusion / ImplicationsData linkage involves more than just use of the repository; it requires establishing common ground since the data have different meaning to each partner. OE developed through SPECTRUM provides invaluable insight into and context for the data. Knowledge transfer among members of the partnership will enrich SPECTRUM's research outcomes while building capacity among Students.

ObjectivesIndigenous children in Canada, including Metis children, are taken into care by the child welfare system at a disproportionately high rate. The objective of this study was to explore factors related to having a child taken into care from Metis families in Manitoba, and specifically from Metis mothers experiencing incarceration.
ApproachThe cohort comprised all mother-child dyads in Manitoba, Canada with live births between Jan 1, 2004-Dec 31, 2014. The factors we examined included the mother experiencing incarceration after the birth of a child, having prior interaction with the legal system, socioeconomic status, maternal age, and mother's mental health disorder diagnoses. Using the Cox proportional hazards model, unadjusted and adjusted hazard ratios describing the risk of a child being taken into care by five years of age were generated for three exposure groups: no incarceration, prenatal incarceration, and postnatal incarceration.
ResultsBefore adjustment, mothers experiencing incarceration after the birth of a child had greater risk of having a child taken into care (HR 9.3; 95% CI 7.7-11.3) compared with women who did not experience incarceration; after adjusting for measured confounders, their elevated risk dropped to aHR 6.1 (5.0-7.4). After further adjustment for prior custody in the prenatal period, mothers experiencing incarceration had 3.8 times the risk (3.0-5.0), and after adjusting for maternal mental health disorders, this dropped to 2.6 times the risk (2.0-3.4). In fully adjusted models, other factors associated with having a child taken into care included receiving diagnoses for a substance use disorder (aHR 2.6; 2.1-3.2) and for psychosis (aHR 2.4; 1.4-4.1) during the five years prior to the child's birth.
ConclusionDue to colonialism, Metis women experience high levels of social and mental health complexity, placing their children at increased risk of being taken into care. Responding to the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's Calls to Action to redress the harms of colonialism is necessary to support Metis children's health and well-being.

ObjectivesOver three decades ago, the Aboriginal Justice Inquiry identified structural racism in Canada's justice system. Although rates of youth criminal charges and incarcerations have declined substantially since then, it is unclear whether First Nations youth are treated differently than non-First Nations youth for similar offences. Our study addressed this question.
ApproachThis retrospective cohort study of youth born 1991-2001 and living in Manitoba between ages 12-17 used whole-population linked administrative data to identify youth charged with a crime (N=13,543). First Nations youth (n=7,081) were compared with all other Manitoba (AOM) youth (n=6,462) on whether their criminal charge proceeded or was dropped, deferred or diverted. The study applied an intersectionality theoretical framework. Individual (age, type and severity of charge, ever in child protection care, youth and/or mother diagnosed mental disorder, maternal incarceration, number of siblings, urban/rural residence) and social strata (First Nations identity, income, sex) factors were adjusted for using multi-level models.
ResultsAfter accounting for other factors, First Nations youth had a higher risk of a charge proceeding than AOM (adjusted Relative Risk (aRR) 1.16, 95% CI 1.12-1.20). There was no difference in charges proceeding for male First Nations youth compared with male AOM, whereas among females, the risk was greater for First Nations (aRR 1.31, 95% CI 1.26-1.36). Low income and a history of being in the care of the child protection system increased the risk of charges proceeding for AOM only (aRR 1.16, 95% CI 1.13-1.18; aRR 1.13, 95% CI 1.07-1.20); for First Nations, there was no increased risk of charges proceeding associated with these intersecting factors.
ConclusionThese findings provide quantitative evidence of the intersecting structural racism in the youth criminal justice system previously identified by First Nations leaders. Future research will follow this cohort to determine whether more judicial sanctions are applied to First Nations youth throughout the justice process, including within criminal courts and corrections.

Problem: In Canadian society, public policies guide the development and administration of social services and systems, including the public education system, the justice system, family services, social housing and income support. However, because social services are often planned and implemented in a 'siloed' manner, coordination and collaboration across departments, sectors and organisations is sorely lacking. Data and resource constraints may prevent services being evaluated to ensure they meet the needs of the people for whom they are intended. When the needs of individuals are not addressed, the result is poor outcomes and wasted resources across multiple areas.Our Response: In 2018, we formed the SPECTRUM Partnership in response to a recognised need for collaborative cross-sector approaches to strengthening the policies that shape social services and systems in our country. The tripartite SPECTRUM partnership comprises representatives from community organisations, government and academia, and is an entity designed to conduct social policy research and evaluation, incorporating interdisciplinary perspectives and expertise from its members. Guided by community-driven research questions and building on existing data resources, SPECTRUM seeks to address specific knowledge gaps in social programs, services and systems. New research findings are then translated into viable public policy options, in alignment with government priorities, and presented to policy-makers for consideration.Implications: In this practice-based article, we describe the key steps we took to create the SPECTRUM partnership, build our collective capacity for research and evaluation, and transform our research findings into actionable evidence to support sound public policy. We outline four of SPECTRUM's achievements to date in the hope that the lessons we learned during the development of the partnership may serve as a guide for others aiming to optimise public policy development in a collaborative evidence-based way.