The National Dimension of Citizenship in T. H. Marshall
In: Citizenship studies, Band 2, Heft 2, S. 165-178
ISSN: 1362-1025
Whereas rights are commonly regarded as deriving from membership, T. H. Marshall raises the possibility that appropriate combinations of rights may be constitutive of membership in the form of citizenship. Theoretical discussion must take seriously the derivation of membership from rights, which requires attention to the concrete sociological process by which rights become endowed with meaning. Marshall reproduces the standard British ambivalence about the "national," which is variously & sometimes confusingly distinguished from the "local," the "private," & the "foreign." The civilization of which Marshall suggests that it should be a "common heritage" is historically situated; in fact, it is precisely because it is in one sense already common that social pressure gradually causes it to be recognized as such. In other words, it is possible to show that Marshall's analysis specifically addresses the issues of citizenship in the nation-state. Its potential relevance beyond the nation-state requires, therefore, explicit discussion of the social basis of belonging that Marshall, for his own purposes, was able to take for granted. 28 References. Adapted from the source document.