Some Disgruntled and Controversial Comments on the Idea of Culture in the Social Sciences
In: Social science quarterly, Band 53, Heft 2, S. 377-392
ISSN: 0038-4941
Current writing about culture is still characterized by conceptual slovenliness. Despite the clear thrust of E. B. Tylor's old definition, persons are still often said to be "members" of culture, which is about as justifiable as saying that a religious ritual, for example, is a member of a street corner gang. In current writing about culture there is also discernible a misplaced humanism that makes it unnecessarily difficult to allow a kind of "objective" analysis of culture that focuses away from human beings, temporarily but very usefully. Emic approaches in anthrop have their decided limitations. There are some older notions bearing on culture which have not recently received the attention they might. Autonomization, hierarchization, alienation & cultural alternation are still worth further analysis. Avoiding conceptual slovenliness & misplaced humanism & further developing the older notions indicated are indispensable procedures for enhancing the at present limited & vague utility of the idea of culture in the soc sci's. AA.