Accounting for the past: the role of public apologies in Ireland
In: Irish political studies: yearbook of the Political Studies Association of Ireland, Band 37, Heft 4, S. 571-595
ISSN: 1743-9078
90 Ergebnisse
Sortierung:
In: Irish political studies: yearbook of the Political Studies Association of Ireland, Band 37, Heft 4, S. 571-595
ISSN: 1743-9078
In: Bryson , A & MacCarthaigh , M 2021 , ' Accounting for the Past: The Role of Public Apologies in Ireland ' , Irish Political Studies . https://doi.org/10.1080/07907184.2021.2020255
Demands for accountability are a prominent feature of contemporary public life. Although much academic attention has focused on perceived denials of accountability and blame avoidance in various political, administrative and transitional justice contexts, there has been much less analysis of blame acceptance and efforts to provide accountability. This paper explores attempts to provide such accountability through the medium of public apologies. It considers accountability as an iterative process that is intrinsically linked to perceptions by target audiences. Our analysis draws on a survey of 1007 citizens across the island of Ireland and public attitudes to apologies reflected in focus groups with a stratified sample of the general population. We find that the public appetite for apologies is strong and that they are generally valued as a core element of accountability provision. Public evaluations of such apologies are nonetheless modulated by a range of intersecting variables. In the concluding section we consider these various dynamics and reflect on how viewing public apologies as a complex dialogic process can inform broader conceptual understandings of accountability.
BASE
In: MacCarthaigh , M & McKeown , C 2021 , A Political Science Perspective on Fake News . in T Chakraborty , S Kumar , C Long & D Padmanabhan (eds) , Data Science for Fake News : Surveys and Perspectives . vol. 42 , The Information Retrieval Series , Springer , pp. 233-243 . https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-62696-9
Contemporary concerns about 'fake news' are typically framed around the need for factual accuracy, accountability and transparency in public life at both national and international levels. These are long-standing concerns within political science but the problem of 'fake news' and its associated impact on the fundamental political questions about who governs and how have taken on new potency in the digital age. In this chapter, we begin by considering what is meant by fake news before examining the issue in historical political context. The chapter then turns to more recent manifestations of fake news and the real-world challenges it presents. A final section considers how fake news has attracted interest in the study of elections and voting behaviour, international relations and strategic narratives, and transparency and trust in government.
BASE
In: Administration: Journal of the Institute of Public Administration of Ireland, Band 67, Heft 2, S. 137-160
ISSN: 2449-9471
Abstract
The creation of Intreo as a one-stop shop for jobseekers in Ireland occurred during the financial and sovereign debt crisis period of 2010–16. The organisational merger was the product of an extensive programme of successful administrative reorganisation and service integration that deserves attention. This article begins with an overview of the policy to merge insurance-based unemployment benefit, discretionary social welfare payments and labour market activation measures, as well as the various political and institutional rationales that led to this development. Drawing on the special issue framework concerning how the interaction of ideology, institutions and interests comes into play during policy change, we consider the contextual factors that facilitated the rapid implementation of the programme and its overall successful execution. Whilst focusing on the success, we also critically point out the inhibitors in the implementation chain, some of which predated the crisis, as well as problems during the implementation process, such as delays in the national rollout and back-office supports. We identify the main contributing factors for successful implementation of a one-stop shop for activation and unemployment services as (a) a high problem pressure, (b) a small and agile implementation team, (c) changing labour relations (e.g. binding arbitration, weakened unions) and (d) a modern communication strategy.
In: Public policy and administration: PPA, Band 35, Heft 2, S. 179-200
ISSN: 1749-4192
Between 2008 and 2015, Ireland undertook unprecedented and systemic public sector reforms in a polity not traditionally considered a prominent reformer. While some of these reforms comprised part of the loan programme agreement with EU and international actors, many others did not. This article argues that the crisis in Ireland provided a window of opportunity to introduce reforms that political and administrative elites had previously found difficult to implement. The authority of the Troika was invoked to provide legitimacy for controversial initiatives, yet some of the reforms went further than the loan programme strictly required. A number of these concerning organisational rationalisation, the public service 'bargain' and transversal policy coordination are considered here. Agreements were negotiated with public sector unions that facilitated sharp cuts in pay and conditions, reducing the potential for opposition to change. The reform effort was further legitimated by the reformers' post-New Public Management, whole-of-government discourse, which situated considerations of effectiveness and efficiency in a broader framework of public service quality and delivery.
In: Köppe , S & MacCarthaigh , M 2019 , ' Public service integration in hard times: Merging unemployment benefit and labour market activation measures ' , Administration , vol. 67 , no. 2 , pp. 137-60 . https://doi.org/10.2478/admin-2019-0017
The creation of Intreo as a one-stop shop for jobseekers in Ireland occurred during the financial and sovereign debt crisis period of 2010–16. The organisational merger was the product of an extensive programme of successful administrative reorganisation and service integration that deserves attention. This article begins with an overview of the policy to merge insurance-based unemployment benefit, discretionary social welfare payments and labour market activation measures, as well as the various political and institutional rationales that led to this development. Drawing on the special issue framework concerning how the interaction of ideology, institutions and interests comes into play during policy change, we consider the contextual factors that facilitated the rapid implementation of the programme and its overall successful execution. Whilst focusing on the success, we also critically point out the shortcomings in the implementation chain, some of which predated the crisis, as well as problems during the implementation process, such as delays in the national rollout and back-office supports. We identify the main contributing factors for successful implementation of a one-stop shop for activation and unemployment services as (a) a high problem pressure, (b) a small and agile implementation team, (c) changing labour relations (e.g. binding arbitration, weakened unions) and (d) a modern communication strategy.
BASE
In: MacCarthaigh , M & Hardiman , N 2019 , ' Exploiting Conditionality: EU and International Actors and post-NPM Reform in Ireland ' , Public Policy and Administration , vol. 35 , no. 2 , pp. 179-200 . https://doi.org/10.1177/0952076718796548
Between 2008-15 Ireland undertook unprecedented and systemic public sector reforms in a polity not traditionally considered a prominent reformer. While some of these reforms comprised part of the loan programme agreement with EU and international actors, many others did not. This article argues that the crisis in Ireland provided a window of opportunity to introduce reforms that political and administrative elites had previously found difficult to implement. The authority of the Troika was invoked to provide legitimacy for controversial initiatives, yet some of the reforms went further than the loan programme strictly required. A number of these concerning organisational rationalisation, the public service 'bargain' and transversal policy coordination, are considered here. Agreements were negotiated with public sector unions that facilitated sharp cuts in pay and conditions, reducing the potential for opposition to change. The reform effort was further legitimated by the reformers' post-NPM, whole-of-government discourse, which situated considerations of effectiveness and efficiency in a broader framework of public service quality and delivery.
BASE
In: Administration Vol. 67, no. 2 (2019), pp. 137-60
SSRN
Working paper
In: Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics
"Administrative Culture" published on by Oxford University Press.
In: Administration: Journal of the Institute of Public Administration of Ireland, Band 66, Heft 4, S. 49-59
ISSN: 2449-9471
In: Finnegan , P & MacCarthaigh , M 2018 , ' A Century of Irish Parliamentary Government ' , Administration , vol. 66 , no. 4 , pp. 49-59 . https://doi.org/10.2478/admin-2018-0032
The occasion of the centenary of the sitting of the first Dáil in January 1919 provides an opportune time to reflect on the evolution of the Irish parliamentary experience over that period, and the role played by the national parliament as the locus of Irish democratic politics. And though the Irish experience of parliamentary politics is not without its shortcomings, there are not many contemporary states within Europe or indeed globally that can attest to ten decades of unbroken parliamentary government from the early twentieth century to the present. In this forum piece, we survey the principal changes to the structure, operation and character of the Oireachtas and Irish parliamentary politics since the First Dáil met in the turbulent post-WWI period. In a final section we look to the future of Irish parliament.
BASE
In: Administration Vol. 66 (4), 2018, pp. 49-59
SSRN
In: MacCarthaigh , M & Molenveld , A 2017 , Coordination in Europe . in E Ongaro & S Van Thiel (eds) , Public administration and public management in Europe . Palgrave Macmillan , pp. 653-670 . https://doi.org/10.1057/978-1-137-55269-3
In this chapter, one of the oldest challenges faced by governments is explored. Beginning with an examination of why coordination has remained such a dominant theme in public administration and management, the chapter surveys classical and more recent scholarship on the topic, and unpacks its multiple and increasingly diverse meanings and conceptualizations. As part of this study, coordination is considered in relation to process, management practice, and policy. The dominant basis mechanisms for coordination measures chosen by governments are then presented, followed by the obstacles and challenges to successful coordination within and across all levels of government. The chapter concludes with coordination considered in a multi-level EU context.
BASE
In: Hardiman , N & MacCarthaigh , M 2017 , ' State retrenchment and administrative reform in Ireland: Probing comparative policy paradigms ' , Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis , vol. 19 , no. 2 , pp. 100-118 . https://doi.org/10.1080/13876988.2015.1103432
Policy choices in response to crisis may carry consequences both for distributive outcomes and for the future policy capacity of the state itself. In this paper, we use conceptual heuristics to interpret policy practice. We examine the underlying policy paradigms shaping Irish government decisions in the aftermath of the European financial and economic crisis. We distinguish between two such paradigms- market-conforming and social equity - and apply them to three reform themes: reconfiguration of public budgets, the public service pay bargain, and the organizational profile of state competences. Our findings entail lessons for understanding the malleability of policy choice, and how state policy choices in response to crisis are framed and implemented.
BASE
In: Public money & management: integrating theory and practice in public management, Band 36, Heft 5, S. 349-356
ISSN: 1467-9302