Cultural Pluralism from Liberal Perfectionist Premises
In: Polity: the journal of the Northeastern Political Science Association, Band 32, Heft 4, S. 473-497
ISSN: 0032-3497
This article offers a critical assessment of some recent liberal perfectionist arguments for the value of cultural identity & cultural membership, in particular the arguments of Joseph Roz & Will Kymlicka. Because these writers ask how cultural membership & identity may contribute to good lives -- & think this a proper question for political philosophy to address -- it seems possible that they may more readily contribute to strategies for securing respect & recognition for cultural minorities than other liberals. But although their acknowledgment of the value of cultural identity & membership represents an advance over neutral or political liberal approaches, liberal perfectionists are mistaken in viewing these features as important primarily insofar as they furnish agents with the capacities & contexts necessary for personal autonomy. While this argument may supply reasons for protecting vulnerable cultures that are liberal in character, it precludes the prospect of accommodating nonliberal cultural groups whose practices & beliefs conflict with liberal ideals & sensibilities. Adapted from the source document.