Constitutional Rules and Patterns of Government Termination: The Case of the UK Fixed-term Parliaments Act
In: Government & opposition: an international journal of comparative politics, Volume 51, Issue 4, p. 605-631
ISSN: 0017-257X
61 results
Sort by:
In: Government & opposition: an international journal of comparative politics, Volume 51, Issue 4, p. 605-631
ISSN: 0017-257X
In: The journal of politics: JOP, Volume 78, Issue 3, p. 836-850
ISSN: 0022-3816
In: Comparative political studies: CPS, Volume 49, Issue 4, p. 427-456
ISSN: 1552-3829
Assembly dissolution is a key dimension of constitutional variation in parliamentary democracies. It conditions the timing of elections, influences electoral accountability, and shapes how politicians bargain about government formation, termination, and policy. Yet, despite the importance of dissolution rules, no measure exists that applies to the different actors involved in dissolutions and records the complexity of the rules sufficiently accurately to capture their substantive implications. This article develops, operationalizes, and tests a detailed index of parliamentary dissolution powers that generalizes to all relevant actors. We demonstrate the substantive utility of the index by examining how election timing powers modify electoral accountability.
In: Parliamentary affairs: a journal of comparative politics, Volume 69, Issue 1, p. 36-52
ISSN: 1460-2482
In: Government & opposition: an international journal of comparative politics, Volume 51, Issue 4, p. 605-631
ISSN: 1477-7053
This paper examines the impact of constitutional rules on parliamentary dissolution, government termination and duration with a particular focus on the likely effects of UK's Fixed-term Parliament's Act (2011). In the UK debate, expectations about the Act diverge. This article evaluates the plausibility of these contrasting views by combining evidence from a comparative analysis of European cabinets with a counterfactual analysis of the Act's effect on the strategies of UK politicians. The evidence from both analyses indicates that fixing the term of parliament is likely to render parliaments more stable, but may also have the unanticipated effect of making governments more vulnerable to failure and replacement.
In: The political quarterly, Volume 85, Issue 4, p. 454-461
ISSN: 1467-923X
AbstractIn the UK the rules governing caretaker situations have historically been underspecified. The UK's constitutional traditions, such as prime ministerial discretion to time elections and its two‐party system, have in the past limited the frequency and duration of caretaker periods. However, the recently lengthened election timetable, new constraints on the executive introduced by the Fixed‐term Parliaments Act (2011), and a decline in the dominance of the two largest parties are raising the risk that the UK will experience caretaker periods more often and for longer stretches of time. In this paper, we offer an analysis of the UK's current caretaker provisions and conclude that the existing conventions are insufficiently detailed and can render such periods problematic and controversy‐prone. Important lessons, we suggest, can be learned from reforms in other Westminster systems, and from the caretaker rules of other countries.
In: The political quarterly, Volume 85, Issue 2, p. 178-186
ISSN: 1467-923X
AbstractThe Fixed‐term Parliaments Act significantly reduces the powers of the Prime Minister to manage the risk of government termination and to time elections to his or her party's advantage. In this paper we ask how the Act is likely to change the way in which governments terminate, their durability and opportunities for planning in government and departments. In answering these questions we draw on quantitative comparative evidence from other European countries that operate with fixed‐term parliaments. Our analysis suggests that fixing the parliamentary term can be expected to convert some opportunistically called elections into regular elections and to stabilise governments toward the end of the parliamentary term. But the Act is also likely to have unanticipated consequences in increasing governments' vulnerability to failure before they reach the final sessions of Parliament. We explore these unanticipated consequences and outline their implications for governing style and Civil Service planning.
In: The political quarterly: PQ, Volume 85, Issue 2, p. 178-186
ISSN: 0032-3179
In: The world today, Volume 67, Issue 12, p. 18-21
ISSN: 0043-9134
In: APSA 2010 Annual Meeting Paper
SSRN
Working paper
In: Europe Asia studies, Volume 54, Issue 5, p. 701-724
ISSN: 1465-3427
In: Europe Asia studies, Volume 54, Issue 5, p. 701-724
ISSN: 0966-8136
In: British politics, Volume 18, Issue 1, p. 21-39
ISSN: 1746-9198
In: The political quarterly, Volume 92, Issue 1, p. 74-79
ISSN: 1467-923X
AbstractThe UK government has pledged to establish a Constitution, Democracy and Rights Commission. This body will have a wide remit to recommend potentially sweeping constitutional change. This article draws on international experience and best practice to outline how the commission might best organise the process to produce proposals which are widely supported, fit for purpose, and durable. We argue that to achieve these goals the commission's organisation should reflect three key principles: impartiality, expertise, and public participation. This would reflect international best practice and build on recent domestic developments. We argue that these principles can best be achieved if the commission works through a citizens' assembly that combines members of the public with party politicians. This would be a new departure for the UK, but a necessary one given the scale of the government's constitutional reform agenda, and its stated goal of restoring public trust in politics.
In: The political quarterly, Volume 92, Issue 1, p. 83-84
ISSN: 1467-923X