Explaining cosmological anisotropy: Evidence for causal horizons from CMB data
The origin of power asymmetry and other measures of statistical anisotropy on the largest scales of the universe, as manifested in cosmic microwave background (CMB) and large-scale structure data, is a long-standing open question in cosmology. In this paper, we analyse the Planck Legacy temperature anisotropy data and find strong evidence for a violation of the Cosmological principle of isotropy, with a probability of being a statistical fluctuation of the order of ∼10-9. The detected anisotropy is related to large-scale directional ΛCDM cosmological parameter variations across the CMB sky, which are sourced by three distinct patches in the maps with circularly averaged sizes between 40° and 70° in radius. We discuss the robustness of our findings to different foreground separation methods and analysis choices, and find consistent results from WMAP data when limiting the analysis to the same scales. We argue that these well-defined regions within the cosmological parameter maps may reflect finite and casually disjoint horizons across the observable universe. In particular, we show that the observed relation between horizon size and mean dark energy density within a given horizon is in good agreement with expectations from a recently proposed model of the universe that explains cosmic acceleration and cosmological parameter tensions between the high- and low-redshift universe from the existence of casual horizons within our universe. ; This work is dedicated to the memory of my father, Marcelo. PF is specially grateful to K. Benabed and O. Doré for useful comments on the draft, I. Tutusaus for advice with iMinuit, and J. Guerrero for help with the Hidra computing cluster at ICE. Hidra is funded by CSIC project EQC2019-005664-P, with European FEDER funds. The development of this project required 800 000+ CPU hours at Hidra. Some of the results in this paper have been derived using the HEALPY (Zonca et al. 2019), HEALPIX (Górski et al. 2005), and CAMB (Lewis, Challinor & Lasenby 2000) packages. We acknowledge support from MINECO through grants ESP2017-89838-C3-1-R and PGC2019-102021-B-100, the H2020 European Union grants LACEGAL 734374 and EWC 776247 with ERDF funds, and Generalitat de Catalunya through CERCA to grant 2017-SGR-885 and funding to IEEC.