Fertile ground, complex matter: Plurality of farmers' attitudes towards green waste application as sustainable soil management

In: Sociologia ruralis, Band 62, Heft 3, S. 509-541

Abstract

AbstractThe adoption of sustainable soil management practices such as the use of green waste from road‐side management and nature reserves is thwarted in practice by hesitance on the side of farmers. To foster the use of these practices, it is crucial to understand farmers' decision perspectives and attitudes towards them. Using Q‐methodology, the perspectives of 12 dairy and arable farmers in The Netherlands were analysed. It was studied which barriers farmers perceive for green waste application (GWA), and whether perceptions of barriers are related to particular rationalities on the position of farmers within society. In Q‐sorts and semistructured interviews, farmers ranked their degree of agreement on 41 statements about GWA, nutrient policy information, general beliefs on soil and farm management and circular agriculture, inspired by a cultural theory framework. Six decision perspectives were identified, globally agreeing on the benefits of GWA but challenged by rapidly changing regulations regarding nutrient management. Plurality in decision perspectives captured the need for trusted information, alongside differing views on responsibility and views on sustainable agriculture. Combining Q‐methodology with cultural theory confirmed the need to include various notions of trust, power and responsibility in understanding complex decision‐making perspectives within more sustainable soil management practices.