A Modern Cinderella: Race, Sexuality, and Social Class in the Rhinelander Case

In: International labor and working class history: ILWCH, Band 51, S. 129-147

Abstract

On November 13, 1924, the first public announcements of white scion Leonard Kip Rhinelander's secret marriage to a working-class "colored" woman, Alice Jones, exploded across the front pages of New York newspapers. Although Rhinelander, a wealthy white socialite, ignored family orders and stayed with his wife through the first week or so of the scandal, few were surprised when he ultimately left her and filed an annulment suit. While New York did not outlaw interracial marriages, Leonard's suit reflected the extent of public sentiment against such marriages. Claiming he had not known Alice was black and would not have married her if he had, Leonard, acutely aware of his class station, nonetheless based his request to dissolve the marriage on prohibitions against interracial unions. It is perhaps surprising, therefore, that the jury of twelve white married men refused the Rhinelander heir his annulment and upheld the marriage, there-by accepting Alice's version of events and actions.