"The God of This Lower World": Leo Strauss's Critique of Historicism inNatural Right and History

In: The review of politics, Band 81, Heft 1, S. 47-76

Abstract

AbstractThis paper offers a new account of Leo Strauss's critique of historicism inNatural Right and History. According to the general view of this critique, Strauss tries to show that historicism wrongly denies the possibility of knowledge of universal and unchangeable principles of right. I argue that this view only reflects Strauss's exoteric critique of historicism, and that, apart from it, he gives an esoteric critique. According to this esoteric critique, historicism ignores the necessity of prudence, in the sense of making "concrete decisions" which suspend universal and unchangeable principles of right. In this light, I also show that Strauss's critique of historicism depends on Carl Schmitt's concept of the "decision," but that Strauss simultaneously critiques Schmitt inNatural Right and History.